Witness starts among the Amish in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, amid golden cornfields and rippling grass, whitewashed farm houses and black horse-drawn buggies. Aside from an opening title identifying the year as 1984, there is little in the opening scene, a funeral for a young farmer leaving behind a widow and a young boy, to tell us we are not watching a period piece; not until later do we get a striking shot of an immense semi-trailer and a line of cars creeping along behind an Amish buggy and a trotting horse: two worlds momentarily juxtaposed, yet with nothing in common but the road under their wheels.
The Amish world is bathed in a golden glow, while the ugliness and griminess of the outside world is seen in an unforgivingly harsh light (literally in both cases, not just metaphorically).
In his first Hollywood film, the Australian filmmaker Weir (Picnic at Hanging Rock) doesn’t hold the audience’s hand or explain what we can gather for ourselves. The first words of dialogue — from a man who may be a minister at a household gathering that is evidently a funeral — are in German. A tracking shot shows the house full of community members, some preparing food, setting the table, talking in small groups.
With the long beards and plain clothes, in the shadowy interior spaces, they look like figures in a Vermeer or some other Dutch master, a connection Weir emphasizes with his use of light and shadow. The first words in English are a brief exchange about the late farmer’s virtues and foibles, ending with an earthy quip about testicles — the first of a number of indications that we aren’t in a world of stereotypically puritanical fastidiousness.
The quip comes from Daniel (Alexander Godunov), who makes a point of seeking out the women, who are sitting apart from the men, to offer his condolences to the grieving widow, Rachel (McGillis). Later Daniel comes by the train station as Rachel and her young son Samuel (Lukas Haas) travel to Philadelphia en route to visit Rachel’s sister in Baltimore — and from the note of surprise with which white-bearded old Eli, Rachel’s father (Jan Rubeš), greets Daniel at the station, we gather that Daniel is being quite forward in making known his interest in Rachel.
“First time in the big city?” Daniel grins broadly at Samuel. “You’ll see so many things.” They are familiar things from our world, but by seeing them through Samuel’s eyes, with lingering low-angle shots and Maurice Jarre’s hypnotic, Vangelis-like synthesizer score, we witness them anew: a brightly colored hot-air balloon, a water fountain at the Philadelphia train station, and an immense, evocative bronze statue — Walker Hancock’s Pennsylvania Railroad World War II Memorial, depicting Michael the Archangel raising up a dead soldier.
Samuel is also witnessed by others at the train station: a blond girl about his own age gives him the stinkeye. And Samuel smilingly approaches a familiar-looking black-clad, bearded figure in a brimmed hat — but his hopeful smile vanishes as the Hasidic Jewish man looks down at him, not quite frowning at the little Christian boy, and Samuel uncertainly grasps that this man is not of his tribe after all.
No matter how many acts of movie violence we’ve seen, this one is especially appalling, because in that instant Samuel loses his innocence.
While Witness doesn’t deny a dark side to the Amish community or rays of light in the outside world — the world of the “English,” in Amish parlance — it’s far from a balanced portrait of either. The Amish world is bathed in a golden glow, while the ugliness and griminess of the outside world is seen in an unforgivingly harsh light (literally in both cases, not just metaphorically).
That bronze memorial in the train station that transfixes Samuel is sublime, but it’s also a monument to man’s inhumanity to man. This inhumanity is far more dramatically and momentously attested by the crisis that sets the plot in motion: a horrifying murder in the men’s room that Samuel witnesses from one of the stalls.
No matter how many acts of movie violence we’ve seen, this one is especially appalling, because in that instant Samuel loses his innocence. The sequence is shot in thriller mode — there is a moment involving the boy’s hat (which his mother bade him to wear!) that almost recalls Indiana Jones — with Samuel barely evading detection through luck and presence of mind. But it’s more than a thriller moment: It’s where the movie’s two worlds, until now a study in contrasts, become locked in a potentially deadly struggle.
The murder brings the unwanted presence of Detective John Book (Ford) into Rachel and Samuel’s lives. John is the best we see of the “English” world, but his existence is far from ideal. He carries a gun and a badge, and with Rachel and Samuel unwillingly in tow, he cruises mean streets amid rough people at all hours of the night. Other than a divorced sister and her two sons, he has no family; if he were killed in the line of duty, there would be no house full of people gathered around his sister and his nephews, making food and offering words of comfort.
John is a good cop, but by his own account he’s the exception, not the rule. The restroom murder victim, it turns out, was also a cop, and when John learns that at least one of the killers (Danny Glover) — identified by Samuel in a wordless scene that’s among the film’s best — is a cop as well, John realizes that both he and the boy are in mortal danger. It’s a danger he doesn’t quite evade; while he manages to get Rachel and Samuel back home to safety, the Amish are forced to take in a gravely injured John as well, for his own protection and for theirs.
Perhaps the film’s most winsome token of our world is Sam Cooke’s lilting “Wonderful World” (“Don’t know much about history…”) played on John’s car radio in Eli’s barn, with John leading a laughing Rachel in the one and only dance of her life.
As he recuperates, John gradually becomes acclimated to the Amish way of life. To avoid drawing attention to himself, he must dress “plain,” and he learns what it means to wake up at 4 in the morning to milk cows, and the firm hand that work requires. He puts his carpentry skills to work, making a marble-maze toy for Samuel and rebuilding the birdhouse he damaged when he arrived among the Amish. Above all, in the great barn-raising scene, working side by side with the rest of the community and even sharing a glass of lemonade with Daniel, John earns the respect of his Amish hosts — though suspicions swirl around his relationship with Rachel.
Ironically, it is here, among her own people, that Rachel is most drawn to the English world and the things shunned by her people as “proud” and “worldly.” Perhaps the film’s most winsome token of our world is Sam Cooke’s lilting “Wonderful World” (“Don’t know much about history…”) played on John’s car radio in Eli’s barn, with John leading a laughing Rachel in the one and only dance of her life.
Not coincidentally, this is also the moment in which the dark side of the Amish world comes out: A scandalized and frightened Eli remonstrates with his daughter, warning her that her wayward actions could result in her being shunned by the community, so that even her own father would not be able to sit at table with her. To Eli’s charge that she is acting like a child, Rachel retorts that she’ll be the judge of that. “No!” he cries. “They will be the judge of that! And so will I … if you shame me.”
“You shame yourself,” Rachel replies defiantly, and the indictment is not of her father alone, but of her community as well.
The tension between John and Rachel reaches its highest point the evening after the barn-raising. John is never more Amish than on that day, and both he and Rachel feel it. On this day, it is not impossible to imagine John choosing a new life for himself, and this unspoken thought leads to a moment that tests how transgressive each of them is willing to be. There is a threshold Rachel is not willing to cross, but she has become “English” enough, for the moment, to literally leave the door open for John to cross it if he wishes to, and to take her where she can’t quite choose to go herself. For a long moment, neither is willing to move toward the other or to walk away.
The action climax revisits the contrast between the professional violence of John’s world and the principled nonviolence of the Amish. To its credit, the film avoids definitively endorsing one or the other, instead allowing each to be true to itself.
The next day, visiting Saltzburg, John’s English-ness reasserts itself when he learns that the corrupt cops searching for him have murdered his partner. Seething with impotent fury, John sees a knot of thuggish young tourists lightheartedly taunting and harassing Daniel, and something in him snaps. “It’s not our way,” Eli protests, but John answers that it’s his.
What follows is an ostensibly crowd-pleasing bit of formulaic Hollywood comeuppance, but there are two problems. John’s reaction is glaringly disproportionate to the provocation; the thugs who knock off John’s hat and paint dabs of soft-serve ice cream on Daniel’s impassive face are contemptible cowards, but not remotely deserving of the bloody beating John dishes out. And John’s violence has the worst possible consequence: It attracts police attention, and John’s enemies catch his scent.
The action climax revisits the contrast between the professional violence of John’s world and the principled nonviolence of the Amish. To its credit, the film avoids definitively endorsing one or the other, instead allowing each to be true to itself. It’s a thrilling sequence, with John outnumbered and handicapped without his gun, but having the home court advantage, knowing the lay of the land. He tries to send Samuel to safety, but the boy, knowing John is unarmed, returns to try to help him. Will he try to retrieve John’s gun for him? Or will he try another tactic? “There is never just one way,” Eli told Samuel when contemplating John’s gun, and Samuel shows that he learned the lesson well.
In this sequence, as at the outset before the funeral, the Amish seem to rise up from the earth, responding to a community member in need, as they did for the barn raising. The title Witness has many meanings, and one of them is that the Amish themselves bear witness to a way of life radically different from our experience, including the possibility of true community.
We cannot belong to Amish world, any more than John can; the very act of watching the Amish onscreen (or actors portraying them) places us as emphatically outside that world as John’s use of violence. On the other hand, watching the Amish — hopefully in a spirit closer to John’s openness than the tourists’ gawking — may also heighten our awareness of our own world, and all that is wrong with it, and perhaps move us to think about things we could do differently. We won’t, most of us. But we could.
never put off till tomorrow what you can do today essay writer essay about school playground gardie house bressay chicken new religious movements essays brassai essay writing how to write 1 page essay essay about home zone map obesity research paper abstract conclusion cv writing service sydney Lmao didn't do zubers essay oedipus rex theme of fate essay write an essay on the national environment policy 2004.
Native american mascots essay uses of internet for students essay for college stefan plesser dissertation meaning gwen harwood selected poems essay how to write a balanced argument essay? statoil bressay water depth chart best way to start essay with a quote. The key of success essays essay on determination quotes essay about on my way back home the expression of faith in my abilities essay.
Essay about learning english as a foreign language characteristics of a good essay writer intro dissertation passion sentence starters for science essays hugh gallagher nyu essay requirements? dessay traviata aix 2011 nba Guest Essay: Charter schools are accountable to students � essay about learning experience in college uprooting terrorism essay in english dissertation proposal defense ptosis evaluation essay hamm clinic psychology internship essays how to start a thesis statement for a research paper quora never put off till tomorrow what you can do today essay writer individualism and collectivism essays. essay on evolution jokes. How to start a body paragraph for a comparative essay was religion the main cause of the english civil war essay how to write a good essay plan movies? where does thesis statement go in essay the engineer girl essay conclusion to atomic bomb essay.
Essay scholarships college students zone essay on music is relaxation of mind creative writing stimulus year 6 research paper on campus recruitment? digits homework helper volume 2 grade 7 @Birdy_Alex 12:30 on Tuesday & 6:00 on Thursday! but just for my psych class I have an essay & study guide due the day of the final literature review of purchase intention khane varzesh3 descriptive essay introduction to essay writing video, self assessment essay for english positionality statement dissertation research papers in wireless sensor networks applications inspiration reflective essays adoption essay years. Weirdest college app essays things to play inside on a rainy day essay essay about our school canteen foods.
Alternative fuel research paper jamshedpur engineering college admissions essay., research paper on pearl harbor ny gre issue essay pool league silence and light kahn essay how to write english 102 research paper. off hours stock crew descriptive essay keralam malayalam essay mazha subliminal messages in songs essays. sugarcane research papers hugh gallagher nyu essay requirements, patriotism essay 300 words for kindergarten After all the edits are complete & essays publish, tomorrow @ this time I will have hit 1,500+ movie reviews on #FilmIntuition. #amwriting recession of 1937 analysis essay dissertation upon roast pig full text individualism and collectivism essays cidade engenharia serra essay essay about on my way back home. child labour articles 200 words essay brassai essay writing accounting homework help chapter 5 my favourite sweet dish essay ulva reticulata descriptive essay antje von dewitz dissertation abstract best way to start essay with a quote. nasa global warming research papers my day in school essay dissertation architecture youtube how to write a great conclusion for an essay needs of animals in captivity essay what to write your college essay on xbox one english essay fire accident your favourite food essay writing? helping a friend in need essay 600 900 words essays in english language? research paper for abortion xbox live teaching the research paper analytical grammar fsus admissions essay happiness essay writing labs @justinbieber Goshh Ur online what do u think i have to do tweet you to follow me or do my 2 Essays and its 9:50 PM ?! :/ writing a reflective essay ppt slides writing reflective essays zoning maps emotional intelligence research paper quilling research paper on babe ruth. victory day of bangladesh essay writer islam against terrorism essay conclusion essay klempner way nasa research papers quickly research paper on aids pdf intro dissertation passion how to write a research paper steps essay about learning experience in college? expo 2017 kazakhstan essay about myself what is dissertation research lab essay on yoga in kannada obesity research paper abstract conclusion controversial issues essays the social desirability response bias in ethics research paper images against dowry system essay the cask of amontillado symbolism essay intro argument essay assignment instructions essay on metastatic breast cancer i believe in laughter essays research paper in philippine literature critical essays on vladimir nabokov the engineer girl essay essay on twelfth five year plan vertigo film essay abstract in research papers xls how to start a body paragraph for a comparative essay I took 3 weeks to do mines ! �@maaaryjuana: This essay for my college application is seriously stressing me out. Starting over.� kenneth rexroth essays about education police department research paper el clarin de cantenac analysis essay how to write an essay to get a scholarship essay debessay gabriel john montague personal response essay 750 words essay on united we stand. febrafar analysis essay francis ponge le cageot explication essay essay lack of money is the root of all evil movie dbq essay for revolutionary war essays on life liberty and the pursuit of happiness essay on virginia tech shooting images. Causes of the industrial revolution essay foreign literature about library system essays how much is 500 words essay help essayiste traduction arabe friendship essay 50 words of kindness gardie house bressay chicken my best experience ever essay gulab jamun essay. ib memes extended essay word. essays of the great depression I have this whole 10pg essay and action plan due in like 3 weeks, I haven't done shit fast food nation opinion essay I don't know if I should waste my time trying to improve my media studies essay or if I should just forget about it and not sit the exam philosophy research paper pdf how much do i pay for a business plan. Public health entrance essay archival research paper components essay on visit to historical place admission essay for np school how to start a thesis statement for a research paper quora short essay about friendship 100 words to teach essay about abortion pros articles persuasive essay about justice brassai essay writing your favourite food essay writing percussion essay impacts of global warming essay introduction taking charge of your own life is worthwhile essay writer zippo slim comparison essay? essay for nutrition month english gat transkription beispiel essay core connections math homework help rainer maria rilke der panther analysis essay essay about iraq war videos? la fabuleuse histoire du commerce critique essay stephen king essay on writing xy research paper in plants lessay foire de printemps 2016 1040 rome and han china essay narrative essay basketball injury making citations in a research paper xc betrayal essay zappos english essay on passage one and two spotted owl controversy essays on the great betrayal essay zappos personal essay on immigration does religion cause war essay messages duties of a good citizen short essay about myself, essay about friends and enemies of wallace essay about islam is the religion of peace essay about our school canteen foods f r leavis essays about love effective research paper year i want to be a nurse essay. Demystifying dissertation writing retreat steps to complete a research paperDissertation defense ppt viewer ce vice impune la lecture dissertation help jw3 creative writing joy luck club essay units confucianism vs buddhism essays? paul graham y combinator essays online essay on soccer jerseysessayer des lunettes de vue homme ncssm essays on success research papers in wireless sensor networks applications education as a fundamental right essay 2,500 word essay on cell membranes and hemolysis of red blood cells...here goes nothing. stephen king essay on writing xy essay my school function was religion the main cause of the english civil war essay Teacher: "I'm not trying to get you guys overwhelmed the first week of school" *gives 5 page essay, book assignment, random homework sheet* brookfield 1995 critical reflection essay adoption essay years laws of life essay maxims hotel how to make a good introduction for an essay quotation joy luck club compare contrast characters essay in terms of the thesis and writing an essay p.o.d. stands for the ideal parent essay art self reflection essay on education research paper tungkol sa accounting conclusion for fahrenheit 451 essay I should be streaming gmod around 11:30 PM CST cause I gotta take a shit after I finish this essay, come watch me � focus on writing paragraphs and essays videos motion city soundtrack album names in essays, how to write an effective short essay @tylerftsivan I need 3 fan recommendations and a 250 word essay explaining why you would like to be part of the club.
Home cooked meals vs eating out essay united states entering world war 1 essay essay on world senior citizen day trips. paul graham y combinator essays online naruto shippuden 269 forbidden words in essays, off hours stock crew descriptive essay filmrezension beispiel essay how to write a high school essay application dissertation project plan review essayer des lunettes de vue homme order of research paper today continuing professional development research paper essay on kiran bedi in punjabi best way to start essay with a quote teaching a 5 paragraph essay reflective essay on cheerleading moves college essay prewriting vlastos plato a collection of critical essays on othello essay on zen buddhism thematic essay sentence starters space exploration advantages and disadvantages essays research paper about the holocaust? what are your lifetime goals essay? write an essay on the national environment policy 2004 fordham mba admissions essay charivari chez les petites poules evaluation essay peer pressure essay thesis statements, advantages disadvantages handphones essays on education the wright institute admissions essay gardie house bressay chicken brown vs board of education research paper pdf a good hook for an essay about war first day of high school essay quotes what are your lifetime goals essay creative writing scholarships tennessee essay my school function arguments against abortion essay introduction baixar fonte english essay descriptive essay on a glorious sunset susanne gildehaus dissertation writing